wheat-free.org

.org

online resource for wheat free food help

Google
 
 

Friday, September 9. 2005

I can't eat wheat, because metal rods told me so

Last month The Guardian did an article on Paula Radcliffe, remarking on what a high maintenance woman she was, and suggesting that she was crossing the line between normal and nutty and on the slippery slope to 'celebrity-itis'.

Her pre-race routine goes something like this, bowl of porridge (low GI), sports drink (energy boosting), put on running kit (special technical clothing), stick a nasal strip on her nose (to increase airflow), stick adhesive straps on her back (to support muscles around spine), pull on flesh coloured compression socks (to reduce calf muscle vibration), slip into running shoes (specially designed of course), put a titanium necklace on (to fight off stress fatigue and improve blood flow) and finally top it off with specially designed sunglasses.

Afterwards, have an ice bath (heals muscle fibres), have a massage (to remove lactic acid), rub on emu oil (for its alleged potent healing properties), drink a glass of wheatgrass juice (for the nutrients), stuff a handful of vitamin supplements down the throat, and eat ostrich meat (for it’s high iron, low fat content).

Now her singlemindedness is something that obviously has made her very rich, and very good at what she does, running. But after the Athens Olympics to my mind she overstepped the line. She consulted a naturopath who held metal rods over items of food, to determine which she should exclude from her diet. The naturopath and her rods told Paula that she should cut out wheat, gluten, dairy, tomatoes, coffee and grapes. Boy are those metal rods clever.

Okay so hold it right there, she has been told to cut out wheat, but can evidently chug back a glass of wheatgrass okay. Now for a bit about wheatgrass. Wheatgrass is the young wheat plant. At this stage the green leafy plant has the look, taste, and nutrient profile of other leafy green vegetables (spinach, kale, chard, etc.). And an important fact, wheatgrass contains no gluten, where many wheat allergies are usually a reaction to the gluten found in the wheat berry. So if you don’t have a genuine allergy to wheat then you’ve got no problem, and evidently a proportion of people with a real wheat allergy aren’t affected by wheatgrass either, but I for one am not going to try it.

So the Radcliff regime now includes wheat-free pasta the night before a race. I’m sorry but I really don’t think that passing a metal rod over a food is going to tell me what I should and shouldn’t eat. In fact anyone that thinks that it is anything more than a carnival trick wants their head testing, not their food allergies.

Food allergy or intolerance testing should be carried out by a doctor or hospital allergy specialist. It’s usually done using a skin prick test and/or elimination diet, and is the only reliable way to determine what, if any, food allergies or intolerances a person has. Not electrical currents when you hold a glass tube of a food, not hair analysis, and not metal rods waved about in the air.
Posted by Helen Fletton in wheat blog at 04:17 | Comments (5) | Trackbacks (0)

Trackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entry

No Trackbacks

Comments
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)

I think its very arrogant to assume that an alternative theropy cannot give you an insight to your bodies tollerance to foods. I took my autistic daughter to a kinesiologist (which seems very similar to the rod thing) where you hold food types and they test your muscle reaction. I was very sceptical but when you have a very difficult child with alot of problems you will try anything. I was told to take suger and sweetners out of her diet and i did so and told no one, from the following day everyone noticed a difference in her behaviour. she went from extremely hyperactive to a more managable child with autism (obviously it dont cure autism) but its made a huge difference. obviously its very hard and unfair to keep sugar out of a childs diet completely but its kept to a minimum and we seem to function better than before she consentrates better at school etc, the big difference we see is when she goes to birthday parties she comes back bouncing everywhere.

About 4 months i decided to take myself and a friend to see her, she told us both to take wheat out of our diets and we did, she saw a huge difference as she was more intollerant than me, her stomach pains stopped she was sleeping less, her diarhea was less. After a month i hardly noticed any difference myself other than pooing daily rather than weekly. after a month of the diet i was feeling down and went away and ate everything reguardless of wheat or not and i was ill for 2 days, i had diarhea, i was sleeping all the time i was drained, had a massive headache. And everytime i eat wheat now i again feel very ill for a few days after. So my kinesiologist and her magnet clearly was right on 3 different people. I used to go to my doctor all the time saying i felt drained and ill all the time they just told me to go to bed earlier after all blood tests came out fine. ive read a few times wheat intollerance gives very similar symptoms of an under active thyroid, i was tested for that a number of times and because it came out negative they just said i was lazy.

Im glad i went to see the kinesiologist its made a huge difference in my life alot more than ive already mentioned, and i find it very sad that someone would pass judgement on these kinds of theropies when you havent even tried it, shes done alot more for me than my doctors. And maybe if there was less arogance in the world towards these things, there would be less problems and ill people.

Maryann
#1 Maryann on 2005-09-23 03:55 (Reply)
I also had a wheat sensitivity discovered by the so-called "carnical trick" of using metal rods to test for allergies. I got sick over the last year, feeling tired and drained and eventually to the point where i was throwing up every time I ate. After about a month I went to see my family doctor, who told me i was fine. Fine?! i was losing several pounds a week and I am small to begin with. I saw him again and he decided to rule out the major things like cancer, ulcer etc., with CT scans, x-rays, blood tests and the like. No results. Basically he gave up and said he didn't know what was wrong with me, by this time, I had dropped nearly 20 pounds to hover around 100 pounds soaking wet. Seemingly out of options, I had a friend suggest that I see a naturopath. I thought, why not?, its not like i can get much worse. After going over my symptoms and using her metal rod tester, she had found one or two items that I should be avoiding, fewer than she had expected, but wheat was the major one. I was told to completely avoid wheat, and by the next day, I was able to keep food down and within the fist two weeks I noticed a real boost in my energy levels. I haven't been sick after eating even once since I stared this wheat free diet. So "carnival trick" or no, those metal rods seemed to find something that my doctor and the specialists couldn't figure out.
#1.1 mellissa on 2005-09-26 14:44 (Reply)
I have been sick and tired for eight years. I went to lots of doctors. Although they diagnose me with hypothyroidism; they told me that they didn't know what was wrong with me. Two years ago I did a meridian stress test to see if I was allergic to any foods. (An allergist had already done a scratch test, but it only showed airborne allergies. The allergist said that a scratch test doesn't show food allergies. I also had a rast test which did not show that I was allergic to any foods.) The alternative test showed that I was allergic to wheat. I stopped eating wheat and felt a lot better. I couldn't believe how much energy I had. It was like waking up from a deep sleep.
A year later I heard Danna Korn, author of Wheat Free, Worry Free, speak. She suggested that I get tested for celiac disease. If my test results were positive she said my family should also be tested. I ate wheat for three months to get an accurate blood antibody test. My skin biopsy was positive for celiac DH. Since then my mother, my sister, my brother, my daughter and my niece have tested (tTg blood test) positive for celiac disease. All these diagnoses are the result of a "carnival test" that was confirmed by blood tests and biopsies. Other family members are still being tested as part of a genetic study to determine the gene for celiac disease.

For more information about this study contact—
Maryam Mousavi, MPH
Study Manager
Epidemiology Department
University of California, Irvine
224 Irvine Hall
Irvine, CA 92697
(949)824-5603
Toll Free (866) 356-9962
Fax (949)824-8482
mmousavi@uci.edu
#2 Sharyl on 2006-03-04 09:25 (Reply)
Like those before me, I too had not been well for a few years. I have had fatigue as a constant companion, cyclic alopecia(hair loss), hypothyroidism, and ostopenia (pre-ostoporosis). The most bothersome symptom was a mouthful of canker sores severe enough that they would keep me from my teaching (and talking) job.
My sister encouraged me to go to her naturopath, who immediately recognized the mouth sores were allergy-related, something four doctors and a dentist never mentioned, over the years. A blood test indicated a wheat, wheat gluten, and milk allergy.
My mouth sores are now pretty much gone, unless a have a breakdown cookie, or unknowingly eat something w/wheat. The naturopath can't say if I am just allergic or truly celiac w/out the biopsy, but says symptomolgy is probably more important to listen too. She did say that the wheat allergy could have contributed to my auto-immune system being screwy (alopecia).
Oh, staying off milk eliminated my life-long bloating and 15-yr IBS symptoms. The ostopenia is likely due to low stomach acid for many years, which causews malabsorption). Years of bloating and a challenge test w/HCL helped verify this. Due to her, my health has changed in a number of ways.
#2.1 Melissa on 2008-06-01 11:50 (Reply)
Naturopaths are doctors.
#3 Deborah on 2008-01-10 20:35 (Reply)

Add Comment

Enclosing asterisks marks text as bold (*word*), underscore are made via _word_.
Standard emoticons like :-) and ;-) are converted to images.
E-Mail addresses will not be displayed and will only be used for E-Mail notifications

To prevent automated Bots from commentspamming, please enter the string you see in the image below in the appropriate input box. Your comment will only be submitted if the strings match. Please ensure that your browser supports and accepts cookies, or your comment cannot be verified correctly.
CAPTCHA

 
Submitted comments will be subject to moderation before being displayed.
 
  • home
  • wheat allergy
  • gluten allergy
  • news
  • recipes
    • starters
    • main courses
    • desserts
    • cakes & cookies
    • breads
    • miscellaneous
  • wheat blog
  • health & fitness
    • autism/ADHD
    • dogs & wheat
    • weightloss
    • diet
    • food for sport
    • slug blog
  • faq
  • info centre
    • alcohol
    • chocolate
    • flour
    • food fact file
    • glossary
    • hygiene
    • product reviews
    • supplies
    • about us
    • testimonials
    • links
    • advertising
    • contact us
  • directory
  • wheat-free ebay
  • BBQ
  • books

Archives

July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
Recent...
Older...

Syndicate This Blog

XML RSS 0.91 feed
XML RSS 1.0 feed
XML RSS 2.0 feed
ATOM/XML ATOM 1.0 feed

Calendar

Back July '08 Forward
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31      
about - ©2000 – 2005 Helen Fletton - disclaimer - site map - links